Law Firm With Close Ties To Gov. Katie Hobbs Awarded Over $6 Million In Government Contracts

Law Firm With Close Ties To Gov. Katie Hobbs Awarded Over $6 Million In Government Contracts

By Staff Reporter |

A law firm with close ties to Gov. Katie Hobbs has benefited from a series of government contracts within her administration totaling over $6 million. 

Coppersmith Brockelman PLC has been awarded legal counsel contracts for multiple state agencies, according to initial reporting by FOIAzona. 

The law firm, which has been a go-to for top Democrats, is also providing legal counsel to Hobbs’ secretive inaugural fund. The firm has disclosed its defense of Hobbs’ inaugural fund as one in a list of conflict-of-interest matters considered adverse to state interests. 

Two of the firm’s partners have been appointed to high court positions in recent years. In 2022, Roopali Desai was appointed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals; she administered Hobbs’ oath of office months later in January 2023. Earlier this year, Hobbs appointed Andy Gaona to the Arizona Court of Appeals.

Last year, one of Hobbs’ general counsel members, Bo Dul, joined Coppersmith Brockelman. Prior to joining the Hobbs administration, Dul had been senior counsel at States United Democracy Center, where she represented Hobbs pro bono.

Coppersmith Brockelman has contracts to provide counsel to the Department of Health Services (DHS), Arizona Department of Administration (ADOA), Arizona Department of Water Resources (ADWR), and the Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System (AHCCCS). 

For all of the agencies, contracts were listed as “competition impracticable” — meaning the state didn’t undergo the competitive bidding process to award those contracts. For example, ADOA designated Coppersmith Brockelman in a 2024 competition impracticable procurement authorization form as having “specialized expertise” with DHS contracts.

The law firm received two contracts in 2024, two contracts in 2025, and one so far this year. 

The two contracts in 2024 were for DHS and ADOA. 

One of the 2024 contracts was for DHS litigation claims related to Sober Living Assisted Facilities at the request of Hobbs’ office; that contract has an initial estimated cost of up to $3 million, with listed counsel rated at anywhere from $350 to $500 per hour, paralegals listed at $150 per hour, and a legal assistant listed at $50 per hour. 

The other 2024 contract was for civil claims against ADOA following a disqualification notice filed by Attorney General Kris Mayes. The contract had an initial estimated cost of up to $2 million, with listed counsel rated from $350 to $400 per hour, a paralegal for $150 per hour, and a legal assistant for $50 per hour. 

The two contracts in 2025 were for ADWR and AHCCCS. 

One of the 2025 contracts was for ADWR related to two separate actions filed in Maricopa County Superior Court pertaining to groundwater rules and regulations. Counsel rates were $400 and $425 per hour, with an estimated cost of up to $120,000 per year. 

The other 2025 contract was to provide miscellaneous legal counsel for AHCCCS, with an initial estimated cost of $100,000 that was extended earlier this year to $200,000. Counsel rates were listed as $350 to $475 per hour, and an associate for $275 per hour. 

The contract this year concerned ADWR’s involvement in an appeal and special action lawsuit on the assured water supply program: Home Builders Association of Central Arizona v. Arizona Department of Water Resources. The contract listed an initial estimated cost of up to $600,000. The state justified competition in this contract as impracticable because ADWR’s in-house attorneys were handling other litigation as well as Hobbs’ policy priorities.

AZ Free News is your #1 source for Arizona news and politics. You can send us news tips using this link.

Gov. Katie Hobbs Funnels $16.4 Million In COVID Relief Funds To Arizona’s Universities

Gov. Katie Hobbs Funnels $16.4 Million In COVID Relief Funds To Arizona’s Universities

By Staff Reporter |

Gov. Katie Hobbs is looking to spend as much of the federal COVID-19 relief funds as possible before Election Day and the December spending deadline.

On Tuesday, Hobbs announced the allocation of more than $16.4 million to Arizona’s three public universities. 

Arizona State University will receive more than $8 million; Northern Arizona University will receive more than $2.6 million; and the University of Arizona will receive more than $5.7 million split between its main campus and its health sciences center. 

The $16.4 million comes from the $4.2 billion in American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds given to the state. The deadline to obligate ARPA funds passed on Dec. 31, 2024, and the deadline to spend those funds is coming up on Dec. 31, 2026. 

Legal forms of obligation include formal commitments through contracts, interagency agreements such as a memorandum of understanding, purchase orders for goods or services, or subawards.

Moving ARPA funds into a general fund without establishing an obligation doesn’t qualify, however.

During Hobbs’ first year in office, she clawed back more than $210 million in ARPA funds issued by her predecessor, Gov. Doug Ducey. The Hobbs administration alleged the funds were illegally issued because the recipients weren’t subjected to a competitive bidding process. Sean Behrens, Hobbs’ senior counsel, said at the time that Hobbs was just following the law. 

“We didn’t have a choice in the matter,” said Behrens. “In the Hobbs administration, we follow the law.”

Hobbs’ spokesman Christian Slater refused to elaborate on the original obligations behind the $16.4 million in a statement to KNAU. Slater also denied that the millions had any bearing on Hobbs’ reelection campaign. 

“I’ll decline to comment on the processes by which we determine ARPA funding,” said Slater. “As the governor has always said, she is committed to doing what’s right for Arizona and putting politics aside.”

Hobbs said the funds were necessary to offset budget cuts from the fiscal year 2027 state budget, which she characterized as the product of “extremist” and “reckless” Republican lawmakers who she claimed were opposed to public education. 

The $16.4 million matches the cuts the state budget made to each university. 

“I will always fight to ensure state universities have the resources they need to deliver opportunities for Arizonans and ensure our employers have a high-skilled workforce,” said Hobbs. “ I’ll continue standing up to extremist legislators and their attacks on public education that kill jobs and make our state less competitive.”

The governor sang a different tune about the state budget less than four months ago when she signed it into law.  

The 2027 fiscal year budget had earned the support of Hobbs and a bipartisan collective in the legislature. 

Hobbs announced her approval of the budget back in June with a press release praising it as “her Arizona First budget” with laudable public education investments.

“I’m thrilled to sign the bipartisan Arizona First budget into law,” said Hobbs. “We’re stopping the data center tax credit for three years, investing in border security, education and water security, and delivering a $1.4 billion tax cut for middle class Arizonans. Starting on July 1, Arizonans will have no taxes on tips and overtime, a higher standard deduction, a deduction for seniors, and next year, an expanded child tax credit.”

AZ Free News is your #1 source for Arizona news and politics. You can send us news tips using this link.

TJ SHOPE: Mayes Must Release The Full Sunshine Investigation

TJ SHOPE: Mayes Must Release The Full Sunshine Investigation

By T.J. Shope |

Over the past few years, a government pay-to-play scandal has been brewing in Arizona that rivals the malfeasance we have come to expect from American bastions of improprieties like New York, Illinois, and California.

A couple of years ago, the state’s paper of record, The Arizona Republic, exposed a troubling relationship between Governor Katie Hobbs and Sunshine Residential Homes, LLC. The reporting revealed a suspicious link between political donations benefiting Hobbs’ inaugural fund and the Arizona Democratic Party and government-approved rate increases for Sunshine—at a time when similar increases were not being granted to other providers.

The revelation of a possible pay-to-play scandal at the highest levels of Arizona government sent shockwaves across the state and launched a quest for answers.

Thanks in large part to media reporting, we now know that more than $580,000 in political contributions from Sunshine Residential Homes and individuals connected to the company benefited Katie Hobbs and Democratic organizations. Then, the Hobbs administration approved rate increases that made Sunshine Arizona’s highest-paid group home provider per child. Internal messages uncovered over the past two years referenced Sunshine’s political connections and even discussed keeping its special arrangement quiet from competitors.

If that body of evidence doesn’t set off alarm bells, what will?

Following these revelations, three state and local officials sprang into action to investigate the allegations: Arizona’s Attorney General, the Auditor General, and the Maricopa County Attorney. Given the gravity of the allegations against Hobbs, each had a legitimate role to play.

But one of them—Attorney General Kris Mayes—publicly attempted to commandeer the investigation into her political ally, warning the other two against interference. Thankfully, the Auditor General and Maricopa County Attorney rejected this politically motivated power grab and continued exercising their lawful authority.

For more than a year, there was almost complete silence surrounding Mayes’ investigation, raising serious questions about her resolve to follow the facts wherever they might lead. Near the end of the investigation, we also learned that Hobbs had refused to sit down for an interview with investigators from the Attorney General’s Office.

Then, after two years—and conveniently just months before an election—Mayes cleared her fellow Democrat of wrongdoing, despite finding fault with numerous actions by the Hobbs administration.

In releasing her findings, Mayes suddenly announced a desire for reform. Even amid a matter as serious as this pay-to-play scandal, I had to laugh at the change of heart and sanctimonious posturing.

Over the past two legislative sessions, I introduced pay-to-play reforms designed not only to address concerns raised by the Hobbs administration’s conduct, but also to prevent future statewide officials from being tempted to travel down the same path. Hobbs vetoed both bills. Mayes stayed silent each time.

When Mayes had an opportunity to support meaningful reform, she said nothing.

That’s not leadership. That’s cowardice—and it helped set the stage for what has become a cover-up between Hobbs and Mayes.

As public servants, we have a responsibility to demand transparency and accountability from government. That obligation was not met by Hobbs, and it certainly was not met by Mayes’ sham report.

That’s why it’s time to shine some good old-fashioned sunlight on the Sunshine investigation.

Mayes must release the complete investigative file, including the evidence collected, relevant communications, interview and deposition transcripts, and the full rationale behind the decision not to prosecute. Arizonans deserve the opportunity to examine the facts for themselves. The other investigations with the Auditor General and Maricopa County Attorney remain open, and these must be allowed to continue without interference.

Transparency should not depend on political party. Accountability should not disappear when the person under investigation is a political ally. And reform should not suddenly become important only when an election is approaching.

Arizonans can rest assured that I will re-introduce these reforms again in the next legislative session—and I call on Attorney General Mayes to publicly support the policies ahead of time and work with me to ensure that these bills become law.

If she refuses, Arizonans will have every reason to conclude that this newfound concern for accountability was never really about reform.

It was election-year cover that would make New York, Illinois, and California mafia-style government officials proud.

T.J. Shope is the Arizona Senate President Pro Tempore and represents Legislative District 16.

Katie Hobbs’ Black Leaders Coalition Includes Senator Behind $1,500 Fried Chicken Scam

Katie Hobbs’ Black Leaders Coalition Includes Senator Behind $1,500 Fried Chicken Scam

By Staff Reporter |

Earlier this summer, State Sen. Kiana Sears (D-LD9) attempted to scam a restaurant out of more than $1,500 worth of fried chicken. 

Now, Sears is part of the inaugural “Black Leaders for Katie” coalition, launched by Gov. Katie Hobbs on Monday as part of her reelection campaign. Sears was named second in a list of 35.

Members of the media referred to the ordeal as “Chickengate,” so dubbed by the Arizona Agenda who retrieved the emails involving the restaurant, lawmakers, senate staff, and lobbyists that shed light on Sears’s conduct. 

The ordeal began after a Republican lawmaker and bipartisan lobbyist group organized an event celebrating the 100th anniversary of Route 66. That event included more than $1,500 worth of catering from the Gus’s World Famous Hot & Spicy Fried Chicken location in downtown Phoenix. The order included chicken, mac and cheese, coleslaw, sweet tea, and lemonade. 

Following the event, Sears contacted the caterer purporting to be one of the individuals in charge. Sears did not coordinate or pay for the event. According to an email from the restaurant’s general manager, Sears claimed in a call that the chicken was “overcooked, dry, and not enjoyed by most” — directly contradicting positive feedback the restaurant had received from event coordinators. 

The general manager also revealed that Sears demanded the $1,500 catering order be remade on Saturday, June 27 at 5:30 p.m. Those who coordinated the event urged the restaurant to ignore Sears’s request.

Sears later dismissed questions from the media about the scam attempt as a “distraction” from her work as a lawmaker, and refused to answer other questions regarding where the catering order would have gone if the restaurant had fulfilled it. 

As part of Hobbs’ launch of Black Leaders for Katie, the governor hosted a roundtable pledging her commitment to minority-owned businesses.  

Gus’s World Famous Hot & Spicy Fried Chicken began with a little operation founded by a Black family, originally called Maggie’s Short Orders by Napoleon “Na” and Maggie Vanderbilt when they first opened in Tennessee in 1973, and then renamed to the current branding after their son, Vernon “Gus” Bonner, who took over the business in the 1980s. The Bonner family has since sold the franchising rights to these restaurants.

There are four Gus’s locations in Arizona, and 38 locations across 13 states.

Other Black Leaders for Katie members are:

  • Corey Woods, Tempe Mayor
  • Quantá Crews, State Representative
  • Kesha Hodge Washington, Phoenix Vice-Mayor
  • Kevin Robinson, Phoenix Councilmember
  • Henry Wade, Maricopa Councilmember
  • Max White, Avondale Councilmember
  • Khara House, Flagstaff City Councilmember
  • Coral Evans, former Flagstaff Mayor
  • Cloves Campbell Jr., former State Representative
  • Berdetta Hodge, former Tempe Councilmember
  • Rev. Sheriolyn Curry Hodge, Community & Business Leader
  • Rev. Andre Miller, Faith and Community Leader
  • Pastor David Wade, Mt. Calvary Baptist church
  • Rev. Brian Wright, The Citadel of Praise, Overseer
  • Connie DeLarge, Arizona Democratic African American Caucus, Chair
  • Briona Parkinson, Maricopa Area Labor Federation, Chair
  • Carla Gentles, Gentles Agency, Partner
  • Karl Gentles, Gentles Agency, Partner
  • Rosiland Moore, Business Leader
  • Kent O’Jon, Business Leader
  • Sasha Simmons, Business Leader
  • Shannon Tolbert, Business Leader
  • Ashley Anderson, Community Leader
  • Dr. Edmon Baker, MD
  • Dr. George Barnes, Education Leader
  • Carla Boatner, Community Leader
  • Dr. Joanne Curry
  • Dr. Karen Hardin, Ed.D Faculty Emeritus
  • Jackie Johnson, Community Leader
  • Dr. Kenja Kassan
  • Dr. Gail Knight, Community and Education Leader
  • Dr. Matthew C. Whitaker, Community Leader
  • Donna Williams, Attorney and Community Leader
  • Rohn Ragland, Student Leader

[Photo courtesy of Gage Skidmore via Creative Commons]

AZ Free News is your #1 source for Arizona news and politics. You can send us news tips using this link.