Two Senate Republicans Kill 11 of 16 Election Integrity Bills

Two Senate Republicans Kill 11 of 16 Election Integrity Bills

By Corinne Murdock |

The Arizona Senate took the final vote on 16 election-related bills on Monday, including one to restore the precinct committeemen (PC) elections, sans its emergency clause implementing it immediately. The remaining 11 of the 16 failed, with either State Senator Paul Boyer (R-Glendale) alone or State Senator Michelle Ugenti-Rita (R-Scottsdale) joining him to kill the bills. 

The following five bills passed:

  • SB1270, to restore PC elections.
  • SB1259, increasing the minimum number of precincts included in post-election hand counts, as well as allowing an Arizona resident or the attorney general, secretary of state, or legislative council to request a recount.
  • SB1329, requiring county recorders or lead election officials to post online the number of early ballots returned on election day.
  • SB1362, allowing voters to have their early ballot tabulated on site at a polling place or voting center, so long as they present an ID.
  • SB1460, allowing voters to receive a standard ballot at a polling place even if they received an early ballot previously, so long as no record of their vote existed in the election system.

Six bills failed narrowly, 15-14, with Boyer being the sole Republican to vote against them:

  • SB1055, rendering election equipment or services contractors liable for damages and guilty of a class 2 misdemeanor if they fail to fulfill the terms of the contract.
  • SB1056, invalidating ballots not included in chain of custody documentation and making it a class 2 misdemeanor to knowingly put a ballot into the collection, verification, or tabulation process outside of the official chain of custody.
  • SB1360, allowing election observers the right to observe, document, and question all stages of the election process.
  • SB1465, requiring the secretary of state to revoke certification for election equipment that doesn’t meet outlined requirements, and requiring at least one member of the Equipment Certification Advisory Committee to hold a cybersecurity certification. The Senate approved a motion to reconsider the bill from its sponsor, State Senator Wendy Rogers (R-Flagstaff).
  • SB1577, requiring county recorders or other lead election officials to separate and record duplicated and adjudicated ballots by their type and defect or damage, compiled in a report submitted to the legislature.
  • SB1609, requiring a court to order an election to be repeated within 90 days if a contested ballot measure or candidate didn’t receive the highest number of votes.

On five bills, Ugenti-Rita joined Boyer and Senate Democrats to vote “no”:

  • SB1359, requiring unique election system passwords for election employees, volunteers, and contractors.
  • SB1457, requiring the secretary of state to ensure that vote recording, tabulating machines and devices meet certain security standards, don’t have internet connectivity, and may track users with unique login credentials.
  • SB1476, requiring ballots to be consecutively numbered with a unique number, and requiring chain of custody documents or logs to track ballots.
  • SB1570, implementing additional voting equipment chain of custody requirements such as access restricted to authorized election personnel, tamper-proof seals for accessible ports, and chain of custody logging, as well as prohibiting voting equipment from having internet access capabilities.
  • SB1572, requiring county recorders to publish a list of eligible voters on their website 10 days before primary and general elections, as well as all ballot images and sortable cast-vote records, and requiring all ballots to be separated and tabulated by precinct.

Ugenti-Rita is campaigning for secretary of state this year.

Corinne Murdock is a reporter for AZ Free News. Follow her latest on Twitter, or email tips to