Teresa Ruiz
Transition Team For Superintendent-Elect Ruiz Led By Anti-School Choice Leaders

November 19, 2026

By Staff Reporter |

The incoming superintendent of public instruction, Teresa Leyba Ruiz, has surrounded herself with several high-profile individuals who oppose the state’s school choice program.

Leading the transition team is Kathy Hoffman, the former superintendent of public instruction that preceded current Superintendent Tom Horne. 

At the end of Hoffman’s administration of the Arizona Department of Education (ADE), she was alleged to have intentionally undermined the Empowerment Scholarship Account (ESA) program by allowing improper spending, understaffing, and poor execution of program duties. An audit found that Hoffman’s team delayed responses to phone calls and emails from ESA families, exceeded the 45-day statutory deadline for 55% of applicants, and released ESA families’ personal information when fulfilling public records requests. 

During Hoffman’s final year in office, ADE was sued for advertising links on its website to chat rooms where minors discussed sex and gender with adults present and without parental consent. 

Hoffman also underutilized $29 million in federal funds, which ADE wasn’t notified about until Biden’s Department of Education sent notice in August 2024. The funds were intended to go to school districts and charter schools beginning in fiscal year 2020. 

Horne reported in 2023 that Hoffman gave millions to vendors who promised to reverse learning losses caused by school shutdowns during the pandemic but were unable to provide evidence of the academic impact of their work or show reasonable impact for the funds received. 

Ruiz also appointed nine former members of Hoffman’s administration to serve on a transition task force: John Carruth, Kate Wright, Callie Tyler, Ben Henderson, Richie Taylor, Courtney Acosta, Sean Ross, Aaron Wonders, and Sophia Braham.

Taylor is presently the chief of staff for Attorney General Kris Mayes, although much of his online footprint disappeared after he issued controversial commentary following the assassination of late Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk. Taylor served as Hoffman’s associate superintendent of communications, policy and government relations, and communications director. Prior to coming to Arizona in 2019, Taylor was the communications manager for the former mayor of New York City, Bill de Blasio. 

Others on Leyba’s transition team opposed to the ESA program include leaders from the Arizona School Boards Association (ASBA), Arizona Education Association (AEA), and Save Our Schools Arizona (SOSA).

Jimmy Arwood, ASBA director of governmental relations, was also a part of Hoffman’s administration; he served as her constituent services manager and public information officer. ASBA is opposed to universal school choice in Arizona. Arwood also served as the government relations director for Arizonans for Quality Education this year, the chief advocacy group against Proposition 320 which would have required most school districts to apply at least 60% of operational spending on direct educational expenses. Voters rejected the proposition during this election. 

Marisol Garcia, AEA president, has led efforts to roll back the universalization of the ESA program. The most recent ballot initiative backed by the AEA proposed to put an income cap on program enrollment, restrict allowable purchases, and eliminate the ability for families to rollover funds. 

Beth Lewis, SOSA director, has long partnered with the AEA to roll back the ESA program. 

Other members of Ruiz’s transition team:

  • Rhonda Cagle – Founder and President of Leverage Consulting Agency, specializing in education communications, organizational strategy, and community engagement.
  • Dr. Ernest Calderon – Arizona attorney, former adjunct professor, and former President of the Arizona Board of Regents and State Bar of Arizona.
  • Brian Capistran – Executive Director of the Greater Phoenix and Arizona Educational Management Councils and former Glendale Union High School District superintendent.
  • Dr. Efrain Casillas – 2024 Arizona Teacher of the Year and Tolleson Elementary School District music educator with 26 years of classroom experience.
  • Dr. Jennifer Cruz – Public school superintendent with experience in classroom teaching, school leadership, curriculum, and district operations.
  • Chuck Essigs – Director of Government Relations for the Arizona Association of School Business Officials, specializing in school finance and legislative affairs.
  • Dr. Jaime Festa-Daigle – Assistant Superintendent of Teaching and Learning for Flagstaff Unified School District and President of the Arizona Rural Schools Association.
  • Kim Graham – CEO of the Arizona Educational Foundation and former educator with extensive experience in education nonprofits and national arts education initiatives.
  • Nicole Guysi – Family Transition Navigator for Encircle Families, specializing in disability advocacy, family engagement, and postsecondary opportunities.
  • Dr. Ashley Hodge – Roosevelt Elementary School District Governing Board President with expertise in educational governance, behavioral health, and social work.
  • Derrick Leslie – Education Director for the White Mountain Apache Tribe and national advocate for tribal education and workforce development.
  • Dr. LeeAnn Lindsey – Leader at NAU’s Arizona Institute for Education and the Economy, focusing on education innovation, technology, and school transformation.
  • Dr. Laura Metcalfe – An Arizona education leader with more than 30 years of experience in teaching, school and district administration, and school governance.
  • Tiffany Rogers – President of Arizona PTA, bringing two decades of experience in family engagement and statewide education advocacy.
  • Ana Samaniego – Superintendent of Douglas Unified School District, President of the Arizona Latino Association of Administrators and Superintendents, and longtime educator.
  • Paul Tighe – Executive Director of the Arizona School Administrators, representing school administrators and education leaders statewide.
  • Dustin Williams – Pima County School Superintendent and former educator and assistant principal with more than 20 years of education experience.

AZ Free News is your #1 source for Arizona news and politics. You can send us news tips using this link.

Get FREE News Delivered to Your Inbox!

Corporate media seeks stories that serve its own interests. But you deserve to know what’s really going on in your community. Stay up to date on the latest in Arizona by signing up to get FREE news delivered to your inbox.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Arizona Freedom Foundation, 835 W. Warner Rd. #101-439, Gilbert, AZ, 85233, https://azfreedomfoundation.org/. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

You May Also Like …

Connect with us!

TOP STORY  |  MUST READ  |  ABOUT  |  NEWS  |  OPINION  |  POLITICS  |  ECONOMY  |  EDUCATION  |  CONTACT

A project of the Arizona Freedom Foundation  |  All Rights Reserved 2026  |  Code of Ethics  |  Privacy Policy

Share This