Nationwide Shoplifting Incidents Increase 93% Since Pre-COVID While Decreasing In Arizona

Nationwide Shoplifting Incidents Increase 93% Since Pre-COVID While Decreasing In Arizona

By Matthew Holloway |

The National Retail Federation (NRF), in partnership with the Loss Prevention Research Council, reported that nationwide shoplifting has increased by an astronomical 93% when compared to 2019 figures. The incidence of shoplifting is up 26% over 2023 numbers. According to the NRF’s, “Impact of Retail Theft & Violence 2024,” retailers participating in the study logged 177 shoplifting incidents per day in 2023. On some days, that number would spike to over 1,000. In addition, 73% of the retail outlets surveyed warned that shoplifters are acting with significantly increased violence and aggression than in 2019.

David Johnston, NRF vice president of asset protection and retail operations, told FOX Business, “This isn’t what we were used to. This isn’t the shoplifting I was apprehending 30 years ago. These are people who are shoplifting because they know when they have an outlet to sell this merchandise to.”

Referring to the onset of organized retail shoplifting groups that resell stolen goods, he said, “Not every shoplifter is going out there and selling their stolen goods online or at a flea market. They’re selling them in larger mass quantities to these local, regional or transnational organizations who are helping to feed the system.”

In Arizona, the opposite seems to be true. Shoplifting is down according to Department of Public Safety statistics from 41,519 incidents in 2019 to 34,587 in 2023, a decrease of approximately 17% with incomplete data for 2024 showing just 29,832 incidents. Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell told Fox 10 that in 2023, her office received approximately 600 submittals for the charge of organized retail theft. Mitchell warned at the time that the number was increasing.

“Arizona, specifically Maricopa County, will not tolerate this type of offense that is driving retailers to close stores, to hurt the communities that the stores are located in, and driving people out of business,” Mitchell told the outlet.

The NRF report shows that retailers who are capable of tracking organized retail theft saw a 57% increase on average in these incidents from 2022 to 2023. The organization is advocating for the passage of the Combating Organized Retail Crime Act, which would increase federal level coordination with state and local level law enforcement.

Matthew Holloway is a senior reporter for AZ Free News. Follow him on X for his latest stories, or email tips to Matthew@azfreenews.com.

Bill To Strengthen Laws Against Organized Retail Theft Is Advancing In Legislature

Bill To Strengthen Laws Against Organized Retail Theft Is Advancing In Legislature

By Daniel Stefanski |

Late last month, the Arizona State House Judiciary Committee approved, HB 2435, which was sponsored by Speaker Ben Toma. The bill would “require a person who is convicted of a third or subsequent organized retail theft offense to be sentenced as a category two repetitive offender in certain circumstances,” according to the overview provided by the chamber.

HB 2435 passed the committee along partisan voting lines – 6-3, with all Republicans voting to affirm the legislation.

Before the committee’s vote, Toma hosted a press conference outside of the state capitol with Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell, who announced her strong endorsement of the legislation. Mitchell took to the platform “X” to share an update from the event, writing, “Thank you, Rep. Ben Toma, for your help in combatting Organized Retail Crime. If you plan to commit this crime, plan to stay. In Maricopa County, we will prosecute retail theft!”

Toma added, “California may tolerate lawlessness, but my bill, HB 2435, will tell criminals that they’ll pay a heavy price for stealing. A big shout out to Rachel Mitchell and AZ Retailers for working with me on this important legislation!”

In the Arizona Legislature’s Request to Speak system, representatives from Quiktrip, AZ Retailers Association, Combined Law Enforcement Association of Arizona, AZ Food Marketing Alliance, AZ Association of Counties, and the Greater Phoenix Chamber of Commerce registered their support for the bill. Representatives from the AZ National Organization for Women, State Conference NAACP, Rural Arizona Action, ACLU of Arizona, and AZ Attorneys for Criminal Justice signed in to oppose the proposal.

The efforts to augment penalties for these organized retail theft crimes continue the state’s already strong reputation on this front. Arizona has an Organized Retail Crime Task Force, which commenced under former Attorney General Mark Brnovich’s administration and is housed in the State Attorney General’s Office.

In December 2021, Brnovich wrote an opinion piece for the Wall Street Journal, warning would-be criminals of his office’s efforts to investigate and prosecute these offenses – especially in the wake of the lawlessness in Arizona’s neighboring state to the west. He wrote, “As Arizona’s attorney general, I have refused to capitulate to the lawless mob…We expect our efforts will deter such theft and hope our task force becomes a model for California and other states.”

Current Attorney General Kris Mayes has continued to combat these crimes, including over the just-completed Christmas holiday. In December, her office announced that it had “seized thousands of cloned gift cards and other merchandise in partnership with the Arizona Retailers Association and with the help of law enforcement partners.” Mayes’ coalition also arrested eight people “as part of an alleged scheme to defraud retailers and consumers.” The first-term attorney general said, “The successful seizure of thousands of cloned cards and the arrest of several individuals reflects my office’s unwavering dedication to stopping organized retail theft across Arizona.”

Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell also has a strong presence against organized retail theft. In 2023, her office announced that it had made 354 bookings over these crimes, which was the most in the county since 2020. Additionally, in November 2023, Mitchell started a ‘Safe Shopping’ Campaign “to stop this fast-growing category of lawlessness.” Mitchell said, “Here’s what I say to the thieves who commit these crimes: we will find you, you will be arrested, and we will prosecute you to the fullest extent of the law.”

The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office gives three tips to Arizonans to help them experience ‘safe shopping.’ Those include:

  • Be patient with retailers. While it might take an extra minute to get an item (decongestants, for example) from behind a locked display, it’s worth it. Know you’re doing your part to keep prices low and keep crooks at bay.
  • Never engage with thieves. If you’re suspicious, reach out to a store manager. Never confront a thief on your own.
  • Keep your personal items locked up. If you carry a handbag, keep it closed and close to you. If you leave purchases in your car between shopping stops, make sure that vehicle is locked up tight.

Daniel Stefanski is a reporter for AZ Free News. You can send him news tips using this link.